Episode check · Supplements and drugs

Do mitochondria supplements and metformin work?

NAD boosters won't slow aging, the episode says. Of 10 studies, 2 agree, 1 disagrees and 7 partly agree.

We checked 6 claims from a 138-minute episode on mitochondria against 59 studies. Most of the episode is cell biology and mouse work, shown in grey. On the lead, NAD boosters raised NAD in people, but most trials found a gain on some measures and not others. The other 5 claims have strong support. Antioxidant pills don't help people who eat well. Metformin lowers vitamin B12 and blunts the sugar spike after a meal, though most of those studies tested people with type 2 diabetes. SGLT2 drugs help failing hearts. Berberine lowers blood sugar about as well as metformin. On cancer, the antioxidant trials lean toward harm.

YouTube thumbnail of the episode
The source we checked On YouTube as of Nov 18, 2026

“416 ‒ The science of mitochondria: their role in health, aging, disease, and much more”

Channel
Peter Attia MD
Who speaks
Nav Chandel, guest
Length
2:18:17
Published
Nov 16, 2026

28 chapters · 6 claims checked against 59 studies · 22 chapters not checked yet · checked Nov 18, 2026 Watch on YouTube →

0:01

Introduction to Mitochondria and Cellular Function

1:43 “most people know it as the powerhouse of the cell because it makes the ATP right and that gives you the power for your muscle your neurons to fire.” Said on tape, not checked yet.

2:29

The Evolution of Mitochondrial Understanding and Electron Leakage

3:30 “What has changed in the last say 30 years and I think I've been part of that revolution. Um is that mitochondria also communicate,” Said on tape, not checked yet.

10:54

Antioxidants, Oxidative Stress, and Ferroptosis

Are antioxidant supplements useless, and sometimes harmful?

Said on tape
17:23
“generally if you're eating a healthy diet I think it's it's the A the other part is that people who are taking gobs of it might be interfering with the normal function.”

Nav Chandel, a guest on this episode.

What 10 studies found

Strong consensus for

8 agree · 2 partly agree

8 of 10 studies agree, and none disagree. In 14,641 male doctors aged 50 or older, neither vitamin E nor vitamin C lowered the risk of heart attacks and strokes, or of cancer. A review of 84 studies found most vitamin and mineral pills do not protect healthy adults from heart disease, cancer or early death. Of 2 pooled analyses that partly agree, the first tied vitamin E to a 12% drop in heart deaths, and the second found mixtures with selenium seemed to help healthy people. Several large early trials could not be read in full and are listed as waiting.

Computed from 10 studies that test this point, each judged by two readers, in full. 10 more studies are waiting for a full read and do not count yet.

Every study and its exact words
Said on tape
16:31
“some cases worse with cancer.”

What 10 studies found

Leaning for

5 agree · 4 partly agree · 1 disagree

5 of 10 studies agree, 1 disagrees and 4 partly agree. In a large trial of healthy men, vitamin E raised the risk of prostate cancer. A review of selenium trials found doses around 200 µg a day raised the risk of some skin and prostate cancers. A review of trials in healthy adults found a higher risk of lung cancer. A trial of male doctors aged 50 or older found no clear sign of harm from vitamin E or C. Several large early trials of beta-carotene could not be read in full and are listed as waiting.

Computed from 10 studies that test this point, each judged by two readers, in full. 10 more studies are waiting for a full read and do not count yet.

Every study and its exact words
18:45

Three Key Mitochondrial Functions: H2O2, Metabolites, and DNA Signaling

22:59 “One is H2O2 needed for immune function as we've needed for cell differentiation.” Said on tape, not checked yet.

25:00

Mitochondrial DNA Release and Aging Inflammation

26:46 “And by releasing a little bit of mitochondrial RNA or DNA over 20, 30 years is causing a little bit of an immune response, a little low-grade inflammation all the time.” Said on tape, not checked yet.

28:13

Cytochrome C, Cell Death, and Cellular Stress Pathways

29:10 “I don't understand. And I'm I actually struggle with it. How does it really work?” Said on tape, not checked yet.

30:22

Mitochondrial Inhibition, Glycolysis, and Organ Function

30:42 “And by the way, here's a here's a crazy thing. A colleague of mine at Northwestern and knocked out components of the electron transport chain. The heart continued to pump on glycolysis” Said on tape, not checked yet.

34:11

Assessing Mitochondrial Function and the Car Analogy

34:26 “I have none without taking a biopsy.” Said on tape, not checked yet.

38:07

Using Lactate Threshold and V2 Max to Measure Capacity

45:52 “All I'm arguing is as we normally age, does the mitochondria become limiting for daily activities or even mild uh exercise to have a good quality of life? I'm not convinced of the latter.” Said on tape, not checked yet.

47:56

Is Mitochondrial Dysfunction an Inevitable Consequence of Aging?

48:26 “It is almost a conflict of interest for me to say that, right? If I want to make a living, I should tell people mitochondrial dysfunction is why you're aging and and lots of people do.” Said on tape, not checked yet.

50:00

Mitochondrial DNA Mutations vs. Nuclear Mutations in Aging

50:24 “Let's say you have to go almost 10fold higher mutations in order to start to see that organism degenerate in a mouse and it doesn't even look like a normal aging.” Said on tape, not checked yet.

52:34

Nuances of Mitochondrial Dysfunction in Aging Beyond ATP

53:44 “So I would define if mitochondrial dysfunction is related to aging, it isn't simply about running out of ATP or running out of metabolites. It could be this miscommunication.” Said on tape, not checked yet.

55:01

Pharmacology and Distribution of Metformin in the Body

57:33 “It doesn't get in the brain. It doesn't get in the heart. It doesn't get in the muscle at appreciable levels.” Said on tape, not checked yet.

1:02:50

The Gut as a Central Hub for Metformin's Effects

Does metformin lower vitamin B12?

Said on tape
1:05:57
“The other one is B12. So B12 levels go down with metformin. So people should take B12. And the reason people don't quite understand why but the idea is that the gut doesn't absorb it as well.”

Nav Chandel, a guest on this episode.

What 10 studies found

Strong consensus for

10 agree

All 10 studies we read agree. In a trial of 390 people with type 2 diabetes on insulin, metformin lowered vitamin B12. In a long US diabetes prevention study, years on metformin raised the risk of low B12. A pooled analysis found the drop grew with the dose. A study of US outpatients found lower B12 on metformin, but no more outright deficiency.

Computed from 10 studies that test this point, each judged by two readers, in full. 7 more studies are waiting for a full read and do not count yet.

Every study and its exact words
1:07:59

Evaluating Metformin for Glucose Control and Geroprotection

Does metformin blunt blood sugar spikes after meals?

Said on tape
1:10:06
“All I'm just saying is that in humans that glucose spike can be reduced by metformin.”

Nav Chandel, a guest on this episode.

What 10 studies found

Strong consensus for

6 agree · 4 partly agree

6 of 10 studies agree, and none disagree. In a trial in 16 adults with type 2 diabetes, metformin taken before or with a meal cut the rise in blood sugar after it. A trial in 20 women with type 2 diabetes found the same, whether the pill came before or after the meal. 4 studies partly agree: the drop was small, showed up at only some time points, or became clear only after exercise. Most of these studies were in people with type 2 diabetes. In healthy young men, a trial found metformin stopped a steroid from raising the after-meal spike.

Computed from 10 studies that test this point, each judged by two readers, in full. 10 more studies are waiting for a full read and do not count yet.

Every study and its exact words

Closer look

Look at who they tested: mostly people with type 2 diabetes

This study agrees

16 adults with type 2 diabetes already on metformin

“Compared with the control, Met (−60 min), Met (−30 min) and Met (0 min) all reduced the plasma glucose iAUC 0–120min ( p <0.01 for each), but the magnitude of this reduction was greater after Met (−60 min) and Met (−30 min) compared with Met (0 min) ( p =0.03 and p =0.001, respectively).”

Diabetologia, 2024 · controlled trial · PMID 38561463

This study agrees

20 women with type 2 diabetes

“As shown in Figure 1A , both premeal or postmeal metformin administration significantly lowered PPG levels at 1, 2 and 3 h after standardized mixed‐meals compared with the condition without metformin.”

Diabetes Obes Metab, 2026 · controlled trial · PMID 41994908

This study agrees

16 patients with type 2 diabetes

“Mean post-MTT plasma glucose decreased from 207 ± 5 mg/dL (P) to 191 ± 4 mg/dL (M), to 195 ± 4 mg/dL (S) (both P < 0.01 vs. P), and to 161 ± 3 mg/dL (M+S) ( P < 0.01 vs. M and S).”

Diabetes Care, 2013 · controlled trial · PMID 23579178

This study agrees

Healthy young men aged 18 to 40, given a steroid

“Metformin enhanced whole-body insulin sensitivity, as assessed by the Matsuda index, by inhibiting the postprandial increase in glucose and insulin levels.”

Diabetes Care, 2025 · controlled trial · PMID 39899467

1:15:01

Metformin Delivery and Organic Cation Transporters in Cancer

1:15:15 “it it lost the organic cation transporter” Said on tape, not checked yet.

1:21:49

Mechanisms of Metformin: Complex One Inhibition and Tumor Microenvironments

1:24:23 “it will not decrease proliferation but the best thing it'll do is they'll stop consuming oxygen and the local oxygen concentrations will start to increase in a tumor which would make it better for radiotherapy” Said on tape, not checked yet.

1:25:33

Metformin and Pollution-Induced Inflammation

1:29:11 “Again there's no human data with metformin and pollution.” Said on tape, not checked yet.

1:29:39

Clonal Hematopoiesis, Cardiovascular Disease, and Metformin

1:32:12 “The second thing we have to know is what is its target? I've argued is complex one and because I've made a complex one that is refractory to metformin binding but works like complex one.” Said on tape, not checked yet.

1:37:18

SGLT2 Inhibitors, Heart Failure, and the Limits of Mitochondrial Testing

Do SGLT2 inhibitors help heart failure?

Said on tape
1:37:28
“So you pee out, you know, they call it sweet pee, right? The urine, you just pee out the glucose uh into the urine and that somehow is communicating to the heart and telling it, you know, a failed heart that you're you're good to go.”

Nav Chandel, a guest on this episode.

What 10 studies found

Strong consensus for

9 agree · 1 partly agree

9 of 10 studies agree, and none disagree. In large trials, dapagliflozin and empagliflozin lowered the risk of heart failure getting worse or of death from heart causes, whether the heart's pumping was weak or close to normal. A pooled analysis of 21,947 patients across that range confirmed it. In a small trial of people in hospital with sudden heart failure, the drug did not ease breathlessness or shorten the stay, though it was safe. SGLT2 inhibitors are diabetes drugs that make the kidneys pass sugar into the urine.

Computed from 10 studies that test this point, each judged by two readers, in full. 1 more study is waiting for a full read and does not count yet.

Every study and its exact words
1:40:00

Assessing Mitochondrial Function and the Warburg Effect in Cancer

1:42:10 “In fact 95 98% of cancers have a very intact electron transport chain TCA cycle.” Said on tape, not checked yet.

1:43:39

Evaluating Urolithin A as a Mitochondrial Supplement

1:47:37 “but where is the target? It's been 10 years. Where's the target? I don't think anybody's ever told me a target or published a target.” Said on tape, not checked yet.

1:48:36

Comparing Berberine and Metformin for Metabolic Health

Does berberine work like metformin?

Said on tape
1:49:39
“But but my point is as far as we can tell and it's in our pre-print paper, people can see it, it it acts like metformin even though structurally it's different.”

Nav Chandel, a guest on this episode.

What 5 studies found

Strong consensus for

4 agree · 1 partly agree

Of 5 studies, 4 agree and none disagree. In a trial in Chinese adults with type 2 diabetes, berberine matched metformin on every blood sugar measure, including HbA1c, a measure of average blood sugar over recent months. Pooled analyses of trials, all run in China, found berberine lowered blood sugar about as well as metformin or other diabetes pills. A review says berberine may match metformin but needs more study. None of these tested the mouse result on tape about how berberine works in the gut.

Computed from 5 studies that test this point, each judged by two readers, in full. 3 more studies are waiting for a full read and do not count yet.

Every study and its exact words
1:52:29

NAD Precursors, SS-31, Methylene Blue, and Hyperbaric Oxygen Lead finding

Do NAD supplements fail to slow aging?

Said on tape
1:57:55
“I just don't see how and it's based on mitochondrial dysfunction causes the mitochondria not to regenerate NAD because that's what mitochondria do let's give NAD supplements”

Nav Chandel, a guest on this episode.

What 10 studies found

Leaning for

2 agree · 7 partly agree · 1 disagree

Of 10 studies, 2 agree, 1 disagrees and 7 partly agree. A pooled analysis of trials in adults over 60 found NMN and NR did not improve muscle mass or function. In 12 healthy men aged 70-80, NR raised NAD in muscle but did not change heart or metabolic health. A trial in 80 adults aged 40-65 in India found NMN improved walking distance and a blood test of biological age. Most trials partly agree: they found a gain on one measure, such as strength or blood pressure, but not on others, and called for bigger studies. NMN (nicotinamide mononucleotide) and NR (nicotinamide riboside) are building blocks the body turns into NAD.

Computed from 10 studies that test this point, each judged by two readers, in full. 5 more studies are waiting for a full read and do not count yet.

Every study and its exact words

Closer look

Look at who they tested

This study agrees

Trials in adults over 60

“In conclusion, current evidence does not support the use of NMN and NR as effective interventions for improving muscle function and mass in adults above 60 years old.”

J Cachexia Sarcopenia Muscle, 2025 · pooled analysis · PMID 40275690

This study agrees

12 healthy men aged 70 to 80

“We report that oral NR augments the aged human skeletal muscle NAD + metabolome while inducing a transcriptional signature without affecting mitochondrial function or systemic cardiometabolic parameters.”

Cell Rep, 2019 · controlled trial · PMID 31412242

This study partly agrees

42 healthy men aged 65 or older in Japan

“These findings indicate that the chronic oral supplementation of NMN partly improved the muscle strength and performance in healthy older men, although NMN did not affect the skeletal muscle mass.”

NPJ Aging, 2022 · other primary study · PMID 35927255

This study disagrees

80 healthy adults aged 40 to 65 in India

“NMN supplementation had a positive impact on the physical endurance and general health conditions of healthy adults as demonstrated in the significant improvement of six-minute walking test, blood biological age, and SF-36 scores.”

Geroscience, 2023 · controlled trial · PMID 36482258

This study partly agrees

Overweight adults aged 45 or older

“The improvements in several cardiovascular risk factors—total and LDL cholesterol, diastolic blood pressure, and body weight—observed in this physiologic study need confirmation in larger trials of longer duration.”

J Clin Endocrinol Metab, 2023 · controlled trial · PMID 36740954

2:05:01

Oxygen Therapy, Hypoxia, and Hyperoxia

2:07:09 “Well, people argue that about hyperoxia as well, right? More oxygen and more free radicals. So again, maybe in those sort of things, but just to take it for kicks because you're going to live longer. I don't I don't think so.” Said on tape, not checked yet.

2:07:22

Red Light Therapy and Cytochrome Oxidase

2:07:42 “I actually don't know how red light um therapy is having its effects in vivo.” Said on tape, not checked yet.

2:11:05

Metformin, Inflammation, and Clonal Hematopoiesis

2:11:24 “the inflammation part people like the best I think I but again it hasn't been it's been the least studied” Said on tape, not checked yet.

2:11:57

The Case for a Moonshot in Metabolism and Reforming Academia

2:13:13 “right now we should be doubling our efforts it's in science especially in metabolism which has been underfunded for 40 years” Said on tape, not checked yet.

How we checked this episode

We go through the episode chapter by chapter and pull out each claim. For every claim we can test, two readers read each study in full and mark whether it agrees, partly agrees or disagrees. A fixed rule turns those marks into the badge, the same rule Precis uses on every page. Nobody writes or edits a badge. Chapters we haven't checked are shown in grey, so you can see everything the episode said.

Every quote is 20 seconds or less and opens the episode at that second. This is not medical advice. Talk to your doctor before you change anything.

All checked claims · How we check a claim

How Precis checks a claim · Report an error

The Precis Weekly

Get each new check by email.

One email a week with the claims and episodes we checked, what the studies found and the minute each claim was said.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime.