Claim check

Exercise and muscle claims checked against the studies

Of 23 podcast claims checked, 8 have strong consensus for, 11 lean for, 2 conflict, 1 leans against and 1 has strong consensus against.

Best for:
anyone who heard a exercise and muscle claim on a longevity podcast and wants to know if the studies back it.
Price:
Free to read, with every receipt. Pro is $9 a month or $79 a year and adds AI Ask.
8 Strong consensus for 11 Leaning for 2 Conflicting 1 Leaning against 1 Strong consensus against

How do the studies line up?

Each column is a claim. Each square is a study.

← Studies agreeStudies disagree →
Can exercise prevent muscle loss with age? (Strong consensus for)Does VO2 max predict how long you live? (Strong consensus for)Does grip strength predict how long you live? (Strong consensus for)Does exercise lower breast cancer risk and recurrence? (Strong consensus for)Can strength training prevent broken bones from falls? (Strong consensus for)Does HIIT increase mitochondria in muscle? (Strong consensus for)Does exercise help depression? (Strong consensus for)Do you lose type 2 muscle fibers as you age? (Leaning for)Can you stop short of failure on big lifts and still gain? (Strong consensus for)Does muscle power decline faster than strength with age? (Leaning for)Does zone 2 training build mitochondria? (Leaning for)Does exercise improve learning and memory? (Leaning for)Does walking after eating lower blood sugar spikes? (Leaning for)Is being fit linked to a younger epigenetic age? (Leaning for)Can strength training and HIIT reverse insulin resistance? (Leaning for)Does exercise burn extra calories without your body compensating? (Conflicting)Is exercise during pregnancy better than bed rest? (Leaning for)Are 8 to 10 hard sets a week enough to build muscle? (Leaning for)Does 5 minutes of exercise a day make a difference? (Leaning for)Does loading an injury work better than complete rest? (Leaning for)Do fewer, harder sets keep strength and muscle as you age? (Leaning against)Does interval training like the Norwegian 4x4 protect the hippocampus? (Conflicting)Can too much exercise shorten your life? (Strong consensus against)
Agree Partly agree Disagree No counted study

Which claims got which verdict?

Every claim checked 23 claims

Other topics

All checked claims

Which claims. One fixed word list was run over the episode summaries of each show. A claim counts the episodes it comes up in, and the claims each show repeats most made the list. A bigger archive repeats more, so compare episode counts within a show, not across shows. A few claims come from a single claim check rather than the episode count, and show no count.

Which studies. For each point a claim makes, we searched PubMed, kept the studies that test it, and ranked them by how directly they test it, then by landmark status, then by citations. Up to ten count per point. Two readers read each one in full and judged its stance; a third reader settled any split.

The badge. It is computed by the same rule that runs on every claim on Precis, from the stances of the studies that test the claim. The quote itself is never counted as evidence for the claim. Only human studies count; a point about animals shows its studies without a badge from them.

What this is not. A systematic review, a verdict on any person, or medical advice. The person named on a claim is where we heard it, credited on the quote.

The Precis Weekly

Get each new check by email.

One email a week with the claims and episodes we checked, what the studies found and the minute each claim was said.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime.