Some say 5 grams is the typical dose that saturates the muscles 14. Others state that taking 10 to 15g or more than five grams improves performance and cognitive benefits 28.
Built only from the clips below. Tap a number to jump to the clip that said it.
01 · Steven Bartlett
Answers it
people were supplementing with five grams a day. That is this scoop here. 5 g of creatine per day. Now that we're getting more uh rigorous with our brain health studies, we have found that creatine has enormous benefits for the brain. But here's the problem. When you have 5 g of creatine, you're saturating the muscles. Okay, remember the muscles are so hungry, so they get first dibs and they take up all of that creatine. So then there's none left for the brain. We also lose a bit of the bioavailability when the creatine goes into the brain. It crosses the bloodb brain barrier, but when it goes into the brain, we lose some of it. So, we have
or so, OK, plus or minus 5 pounds out to about 250 pounds, 10 to 15g of creatine per day is probably more appropriate for you than is 5 grams, meaning it's going to be more effective for enhancing physical performance. And perhaps again, perhaps even cognitive performance as well. And if you're somebody who weighs 180 pounds down to say 130 pounds, 5 grams of creatine per day is probably sufficient. The point here is if you are taking creatine, again, not everyone has to take creatine. There's no law that says that you have to take creatine. Some people don't like it. I know some people fear it's going to make their hair fall out. We already talked about that in previous episodes and the lack of data to support that idea.
should be taking it for the the benefits on on muscle you know AB you know explosive power ex those you know high intensity moments um you mentioned earlier about 0.1 gram per kilogram body weight so how would you adjust let's say you know you're taking 10 grams of creatine per day and you're wanting the effects of the benefits of muscle bone brain as do I however I do not weigh as much as you so would you is there a scalable amount per kilogram body weight you think would be something that or is it hard that's an excellent question and the answer would probably be no because when we go on the scale we don't
of creatine, taking it a bunch of times per day and then backing off? Or just taking it consistently at the-- I think 5 grams per day is the typical dose that people take. LAYNE NORTON: So again, no solutions, only trade-offs. You can load it. And you will saturate your phosphocreatine stores faster, usually within a week. If you just take 5 grams per day, it'll take two, three, four weeks. But you will get to the same place. And you're probably going to have a much lower risk of GI issues. Creatine can be a gut irritant. If it is for some folks, I would recommend splitting it
still the best one and that's just because it has the largest evidence base um you can maybe make some arguments for some other types but you're really going to reach saturation pretty quickly within a matter of weeks and there um at a dosage of anywhere between like 3 to six grams per day um now five grams is the very standard number we give reality is I change that number based on size that's just the honest truth um if you're 225 PBS you're not going to get the same dosage of creatine as 125 pound girl that's just just like this is not what we're going to do so we may slide that number down a little bit closer to three for the the smaller girl boy doesn't matter it's just Fe physical size if you're one of our 275 or 330 lb
isotope? Are they labeling the creatine? I believe they were using an isotope. They're not using like CSF levels or anything. I believe it was an isotope. Okay. Um, and but don't hold me to it because, you know, I I don't remember exactly. Um, you need more creatine. I know. Um, but the 10 grams was where creatine was now was not rate limited. It was Yeah, exactly. Now you were you were increasing levels of creatine in the brain. Pretty sure it was. um rad isotope labeled. So essentially 10 gram. Yeah, 10 you have to double that. And that's where you know I was like okay the sorry just to be clear I keep I'm sorry to interrupt you. Does that mean that
something that we get from the diet but that you can supplement with it to get more regarding you know how much you should take I think that currently the recommendations and you know based on what um Dr Stu Phillips and Le Norton and others said taking 5 to 10 gram per day appears to be the optimal dose if you're a bit larger you could maybe you know take 10 to 15 but even five grams per day after a while will probably saturate your muscle creatine stores especially if you're consuming a lot of meat which does contain creatine too so you're getting some from your diet and supplementing so in regards to how to dose uh there was once a thought that you had to do this loading dose when you
and it was useful data but it it in some ways it was kind of uh frustrating because they basically showed we take five grams a day you get increases in lean mass and strength and performance you take more than five grams a day you also get increases in lean mass and performance but it's hard to kind of compare them directly based on the way they did the meta-analysis and then they also looked at okay if we just take them on lifting days okay you get benefits if you take them on non-lifting days you also get benefits what I would say is that you probably can get away with just taking it on lifting days um but keep in mind that the benefits of creatine are an accumulation so you've
grams a day you also get increases in lean mass in performance but it's hard to kind of compare them directly based on the way they did The Meta analysis and then they also looked at okay if we just take them on lifting days okay you get benefits if you take them on non-lifting days you also get benefits what I would say is that you probably can get away with just taking on lifting days um but keep in mind that the benefits of creatine are an accumulation so you've really got to saturate the muscle cell that's that's that's the key cuz when we were kids you would load it you would do like I feel like you did 30 grams a day for a week or something crazy and then five gr
lifting weights but so it improves like agility agility and speed. And would you for my daughter give her five? Yeah. Of course. Also she's she's studying hard like does she just need the full Exactly. Um, good question because she is almost an adult, right? I mean, I don't I think she's done. If it were me, I would do 10. All right. If it was my daughter. Um, that Yeah, there's, you know, there's actually some studies that have been done in college students who are undergoing like taking a test and stuff. And of course, you're sleep deprived when you're studying for the test and the creatine improves test score. So, I'm I'm all in on the creatine. My creatine budget literally the household creatine budget just went up
So anything else? We didn't talk about the creatine dose. I mean, yep. I mean, typically I mean, like I said, Darren Kando just was on the podcast and talked about typically for muscle like five grams, but uh reasons to go up for cognitive. Yeah. I mean, Darren's published so much in this in this world. Um, we don't use the five gram number at all for the most part. As I've said a couple times now, it's because we deal with humans that are literally triple the size of each other. 0.1 gram per kilogram body weight is what I think he said. Exactly. Right. Which translates to a lot of people as like 3 to five grams, right? Um, where we probably spend more of our time is like 7 and 1 half to 12 and a half grams most of the time. Um, we'll go as low as three. No
maintenance dose which was five grams per day. Um, and the idea back then was that you need to do a wash out every 20 weeks or so where you just stop taking it, you urinate out a bunch of water, and then you re reload. And I confess, I've continued to do this minus the grape juice, but occasionally I'll do the grape juice thing. I don't think there's any real merit to the loading phase, maintenance phase idea. But back then and still now, I feel like creatine has made me feel great, um, stronger. Um, I did I wasn't aware of the cognitive benefits. They weren't being studied back then. >> They weren't being studied back then. But what are your thoughts on why creatine suddenly has become this like
Clips play on YouTube from the exact second. The words under each clip are auto-captions, so spellings can be off.
Ask next
Now make it about you
These clips answer the question for everyone. Tell Ask Precis your age, what you take and your lab numbers, and it answers for you, with a link to every source.