A claim you hear on longevity podcasts

Is collagen a poor protein for building muscle?

Leaning for. Of 9 studies that test it, 4 agree, 4 partly agree and 1 disagrees.

Best for:
Anyone using collagen protein powder to build muscle
Price:
Free to read, with every receipt. Pro is $9 a month or $79 a year and adds AI Ask.

The claim checked: Collagen is an incomplete protein, so it is not a complete protein for building muscle Hear it at 34:56

PrecisRECEIPT FOR A CLAIM


Is collagen a poor protein for building muscle?


  • 3 × TrialAGREE
  • 2 × TrialPARTLY
  • 1 × ReviewAGREE
  • 1 × Combined analysisPARTLY
  • 1 × StudyPARTLY
  • 1 × TrialDISAGREE

FROM: American Journal of Clinical Nutrition


TOTAL4 AGREE / 4 PARTLY / 1 DISAGREE

Leaning for

What do the studies say?

Leaning for

Of 9 studies, 4 agree, 1 disagrees and 4 partly agree. In women aged 60-80, whey raised muscle building more than collagen, at rest and after exercise. In young adults who lift, whey raised muscle building and collagen did not. But in a trial of overweight men who did not train, collagen and whey led to the same gain in fat-free mass. Many studies compared collagen only with a dummy pill, so they could not test it against whey and are not counted. Collagen is the main protein in skin, bones and tendons.

Computed from 9 studies that test this point, each judged by two readers, in full. 10 more studies are waiting for a full read and do not count yet.

What was said on the podcast?

“it doesn't have all the nine essential amino acids and it doesn't have enough of the right amount of leucine. So it's not a complete protein for building muscle.”
Mark Hyman, The Doctor's Farmacy · How Much Protein Do You Actually Need? (Most People Are Getting This Wrong) · 34:56 on YouTube
Episode check A protein meal needs a set dose of leucine to build muscle, the episode says. Of 10 studies, none agree and 5 disagree. 6 claims checked against 66 studies · 10 chapters not checked yet See the whole episode →
The point checked Leaning for

Collagen protein builds muscle less well than a complete protein such as whey

Agree 4

controlled trial · 2020

“Rates of integrated MyoPS were significantly greater in WP than in CP in both Rest and Exercise (P < 0.0001).”

Whey protein but not collagen peptides stimulate acute and longer-term muscle protein synthesis with and without resistance exercise in healthy older women: a randomized controlled trial. Am J Clin Nutr
Who: Healthy older women aged 60-80 (mean about 68 y), nonsmokers, nondiabetic, 3,500-10,000 steps/day
PMID 31919527

controlled trial · 2023

“In contrast to whey protein, collagen protein ingestion did not elevate myofibrillar protein synthesis rates.”

Collagen Protein Ingestion during Recovery from Exercise Does Not Increase Muscle Connective Protein Synthesis Rates. Med Sci Sports Exerc
Who: Healthy, recreationally active young men and women (25 ± 4 y) with more than 6 months of resistance training experience
PMID 37202878

controlled trial · 2024

“Manipulating dietary protein to increase daily consumption of higher-quality—whey and pea but not collagen—proteins by targeting the lowest protein-containing meals offers a viable strategy to enhance integrated MPS in older adults.”

The effects of whey, pea, and collagen protein supplementation beyond the recommended dietary allowance on integrated myofibrillar protein synthetic rates in older males: a randomized controlled trial. Am J Clin Nutr
Who: Healthy older men aged 65-80 (72 ± 4 y), not vegan or vegetarian, no structured exercise
PMID 38762187

systematic review · 2021

“Two studies observed a higher increase in muscle protein synthesis with whey protein and lactalbumin vs COL (Oikawa et al. 2020a , b ).”

The effects of collagen peptide supplementation on body composition, collagen synthesis, and recovery from joint injury and exercise: a systematic review. Amino Acids
Who: Adults over 18 who were athletic or recreationally active, had joint injuries, or early sarcopenia (plus healthy older women and pre-menopausal women) in 15 double-blind RCTs; only 2 trials compared collagen with a complete protein (whey or lactalbumin)
PMID 34491424

Partly agree 4

pooled analysis · 2021

“However, although we found a significant effect of protein source/quality on changes in strength with prolonged resistance exercise training, protein source/quality was not associated with favorable changes to lean body mass compared with the lower-quality control proteins.”

Protein Source and Quality for Skeletal Muscle Anabolism in Young and Older Adults: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. J Nutr
Who: Healthy young (mean age 18-35 y) and older (mean age >=60 y) adults; mostly men; comparisons mainly whey vs casein, soy, milk or other proteins, with one whey vs collagen study (older women, acute MPS only)
PMID 33851213

other primary study · 2018

“are now required to directly assess the acute effects of whey versus collagen protein feeding”

Whey Protein Augments Leucinemia and Postexercise p70S6K1 Activity Compared With a Hydrolyzed Collagen Blend When in Recovery From Training With Low Carbohydrate Availability. Int J Sport Nutr Exerc Metab
Who: Recreational male cyclists (25 ± 3 y, VO2peak 56.5 ml/kg/min) training 3-10 h/week, exercising with low carbohydrate availability
PMID 29757056

controlled trial · 2019

“There was no difference in body mass, waist circumference, SAD and total lean body mass at the end of the intervention ( p > 0.05).”

Whey Protein Supplementation Compared to Collagen Increases Blood Nesfatin Concentrations and Decreases Android Fat in Overweight Women: A Randomized Double-Blind Study. Nutrients
Who: Overweight women aged 20-58 with BMI ≥ 25 kg/m2, keeping their usual diet and lifestyle (no resistance training or caloric restriction); 52 randomized, 37 completed
PMID 31480676

controlled trial · 2025

“In conclusion, dileucine-enriched essential amino acids and branched-chain amino acids supported greater leucine retention for whole-body anabolism compared with COL after resistance exercise independent of attenuation in estimates of myofibrillar protein breakdown.”

Dileucine-supplemented essential amino acids support whole-body anabolism after resistance exercise and serum-stimulated cell-based anabolism. J Int Soc Sports Nutr
Who: 12 healthy recreationally active adults (8 men, 4 women), mean age 27.0 ± 4.7 years; ex vivo arm used their serum on C2C12 (mouse) myotubes
PMID 41321015

Disagree 1

controlled trial · 2021

“In addition, there were no significant differences between collagen peptides and whey protein with respect to changes in fat free mass.”

The Influence of Specific Bioactive Collagen Peptides on Body Composition and Muscle Strength in Middle-Aged, Untrained Men: A Randomized Controlled Trial. Int J Environ Res Public Health
Who: Overweight/obese untrained men aged 30-60 (BMI 27.5-35, fat mass >25%), sedentary
PMID 33946565

More on food and fasting

The Precis Weekly

Get each new check by email.

One email a week with the claims and episodes we checked, what the studies found and the minute each claim was said.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime.