By Arun AgrahriLast reviewed 2 timecoded sources
Short answer
No. The evidence strongly backs cardio for health and a longer life and finds it weak for weight loss. In a pooled analysis of cohort studies, 150 minutes a week of moderate to vigorous activity went with a 26% lower risk of type 2 diabetes. In a pooled analysis of trials, that much aerobic exercise took off 2.79 kg.
A higher VO2 max lowers the risk of death from all causes.
The verdict on VO2 Max overall. 14 sources: 12 positive, 1 partly, 1 negative
positive partly neutral negative Each researcher and each study counts once per claim, however often they come up.
Cardio is a strong tool for health and longevity even though it is weak for weight loss.
17 sources: 13 positive, 3 partly, 1 negative.
Researchers say
3 partly
Doctor Jason Fung, on The Diary Of A CEO, at 32:25
Partly Video · Opinion
Open the tape at 32:25 →“so very very important but in terms of weight loss it's actually a very very small effect”
Dr Michael Israetel, on The Diary Of A CEO, at 1:11:32
Partly Video · Opinion
Open the tape at 1:11:32 →“600s a drop and the bucket to that you'll never notice”
Dr. Lauren Colenso-Semple, on Huberman Lab, at 50:31
Partly Video · Opinion
Open the tape at 50:31 →“a lot of people are adding cardio for weight loss goals and that is a bit of a fool's errand”
Studies show
13 positive, 1 negative
14 papers we read
Pooled analysis, Cochrane Database Syst Rev, 2006, PMID 17054187
Positive Study
Read the paper on PubMed →When compared with no treatment, exercise resulted in small weight losses across studies.
Controlled trial, PLoS One, 2009, PMID 19223984
Positive Study
Read the paper on PubMed →In this study of previously sedentary, overweight or obese, postmenopausal women we observed no difference in the actual and predicted weight loss with 4 and 8 KKW of exercise (72 and 136 minutes respectively), while the 12 KKW (194 minutes) produced only about half of the predicted weight loss.
Controlled trial, Obesity (Silver Spring), 2012, PMID 21494229
Positive Study
Read the paper on PubMed →Participants in the diet alone group lost a mean 7.2 kg (−8.5%, P<0.0001), those in the exercise alone group lost a mean 2.0 kg (−2.4%, P=0.034), while those in the diet + exercise group lost a mean 8.9 kg (−10.8%, P<0.0001), each compared to a 0.7 kg decrease among controls.
Pooled analysis, Circulation, 2011, PMID 21810663
Positive Study
Read the paper on PubMed →Individuals who engaged in the equivalent of 150 min/week of moderate-intensity LTPA (minimum amount, 2008 US federal guidelines) had a 14% lower CHD risk (relative risk (RR) = 0.86; 95% confidence interval (CI), 0.77–0.96), compared with those reporting no LTPA.
Controlled trial, J Appl Physiol (1985), 2012, PMID 23019316
Positive Study
Read the paper on PubMed →Body mass significantly decreased in the AT and AT/RT but significantly increased in RT.
Pooled analysis, J Am Heart Assoc, 2013, PMID 23525435
Positive Study
Read the paper on PubMed →The effect of endurance training on SBP ( P <0.0001) and DBP ( P <0.0001) was greatest in 26 study groups with hypertensive participants (−8.3 [−10.7 to −6.0]/−5.2 [−6.9 to −3.4] mm Hg) compared with groups with participants with prehypertension (−4.3 [−7.7 to −0.90]/−1.7 [−2.7 to −0.68] mm Hg) or normal BP (−0.75 [−2.2 to +0.69]/−1.1 [−2.2 to −0.068] mm Hg).
Trial or observed group, J Am Coll Cardiol, 2014, PMID 25082581
Positive Study
Read the paper on PubMed →This study may motivate healthy but sedentary individuals to begin and continue running for substantial and attainable mortality benefits.
Pooled analysis, J Acad Nutr Diet, 2014, PMID 25257365
Positive Study
Read the paper on PubMed →Pooled results showed that weight loss at 3 to 6 months was significantly higher in combined programs than in those that involved physical activity alone (mean difference=–5.33 kg; 95% CI –7.61 to –3.04).
Pooled analysis, Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act, 2014, PMID 25344355
Positive Study
Read the paper on PubMed →Conclusions Walking and cycling confer 11% and 10% reductions in risk of ACM in groups that conduct 11.25 MET.hours per week.
Pooled analysis, J Am Heart Assoc, 2016, PMID 27628572
Positive Study
Read the paper on PubMed →Our findings suggest that an increase in 11.25 MET h/week for an inactive individual is associated with a reduction of risk for cardiovascular mortality by 23% and diabetes mellitus incidence by 26%, independent of body weight.
Pooled analysis, Diabetologia, 2016, PMID 27747395
Positive Study
Read the paper on PubMed →Using the restricted cubic splines model, accumulating an activity volume which is commensurate with adherence to the current public health recommendations of 150 min of MVPA per week compared with sedentary individuals was associated with a reduction in the risk of type 2 diabetes by 26% (95% CI 20%, 31%) in the general population.
Pooled analysis, Br J Sports Med, 2023, PMID 36854652
Positive Study
Read the paper on PubMed →Compared with inactive individuals, adults accumulating 8.75 mMET-hours/week had 31% (95% CI 27 to 35) and 29% (95% CI 23 to 34) lower risk of all-cause and CVD mortality, respectively, whereas the risk difference for total cancer mortality was 15% (95% CI 11 to 19).
Pooled analysis, JAMA Netw Open, 2024, PMID 39724371
Positive Study
Read the paper on PubMed →The degree of weight loss was −2.79 kg (95% CI, −3.29 to −2.29 kg) at 150 minutes per week and −4.19 kg (95% CI, −5.98 to −2.41 kg) at 300 minutes per week (eTable 19 in Supplement 1 ).
Controlled trial, Obesity (Silver Spring), 2013, PMID 23592678
Negative Study
Read the paper on PubMed →Body weight/composition Weight change over the 10 month intervention in both the 400 (-3.9 ± 4.9; 4.3%) and 600 (-5.2 ± 5.6 kg; 5.7%) kcal/session groups was significantly different than control [(0.5 ± 3.5 kg; 0.5%); Table 3 ]; however, weight change between exercise groups did not differ significantly.
Pooled analysis, Cochrane Database Syst Rev, 2006, PMID 17054187 Study · positive
When compared with no treatment, exercise resulted in small weight losses across studies.
Controlled trial, PLoS One, 2009, PMID 19223984 Study · positive
In this study of previously sedentary, overweight or obese, postmenopausal women we observed no difference in the actual and predicted weight loss with 4 and 8 KKW of exercise (72 and 136 minutes respectively), while the 12 KKW (194 minutes) produced only about half of the predicted weight loss.
Controlled trial, Obesity (Silver Spring), 2012, PMID 21494229 Study · positive
Participants in the diet alone group lost a mean 7.2 kg (−8.5%, P<0.0001), those in the exercise alone group lost a mean 2.0 kg (−2.4%, P=0.034), while those in the diet + exercise group lost a mean 8.9 kg (−10.8%, P<0.0001), each compared to a 0.7 kg decrease among controls.
Pooled analysis, Circulation, 2011, PMID 21810663 Study · positive
Individuals who engaged in the equivalent of 150 min/week of moderate-intensity LTPA (minimum amount, 2008 US federal guidelines) had a 14% lower CHD risk (relative risk (RR) = 0.86; 95% confidence interval (CI), 0.77–0.96), compared with those reporting no LTPA.
Controlled trial, J Appl Physiol (1985), 2012, PMID 23019316 Study · positive
Body mass significantly decreased in the AT and AT/RT but significantly increased in RT.
Pooled analysis, J Am Heart Assoc, 2013, PMID 23525435 Study · positive
The effect of endurance training on SBP ( P <0.0001) and DBP ( P <0.0001) was greatest in 26 study groups with hypertensive participants (−8.3 [−10.7 to −6.0]/−5.2 [−6.9 to −3.4] mm Hg) compared with groups with participants with prehypertension (−4.3 [−7.7 to −0.90]/−1.7 [−2.7 to −0.68] mm Hg) or normal BP (−0.75 [−2.2 to +0.69]/−1.1 [−2.2 to −0.068] mm Hg).
Trial or observed group, J Am Coll Cardiol, 2014, PMID 25082581 Study · positive
This study may motivate healthy but sedentary individuals to begin and continue running for substantial and attainable mortality benefits.
Pooled analysis, J Acad Nutr Diet, 2014, PMID 25257365 Study · positive
Pooled results showed that weight loss at 3 to 6 months was significantly higher in combined programs than in those that involved physical activity alone (mean difference=–5.33 kg; 95% CI –7.61 to –3.04).
Pooled analysis, Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act, 2014, PMID 25344355 Study · positive
Conclusions Walking and cycling confer 11% and 10% reductions in risk of ACM in groups that conduct 11.25 MET.hours per week.
Pooled analysis, J Am Heart Assoc, 2016, PMID 27628572 Study · positive
Our findings suggest that an increase in 11.25 MET h/week for an inactive individual is associated with a reduction of risk for cardiovascular mortality by 23% and diabetes mellitus incidence by 26%, independent of body weight.
Pooled analysis, Diabetologia, 2016, PMID 27747395 Study · positive
Using the restricted cubic splines model, accumulating an activity volume which is commensurate with adherence to the current public health recommendations of 150 min of MVPA per week compared with sedentary individuals was associated with a reduction in the risk of type 2 diabetes by 26% (95% CI 20%, 31%) in the general population.
Pooled analysis, Br J Sports Med, 2023, PMID 36854652 Study · positive
Compared with inactive individuals, adults accumulating 8.75 mMET-hours/week had 31% (95% CI 27 to 35) and 29% (95% CI 23 to 34) lower risk of all-cause and CVD mortality, respectively, whereas the risk difference for total cancer mortality was 15% (95% CI 11 to 19).
Pooled analysis, JAMA Netw Open, 2024, PMID 39724371 Study · positive
The degree of weight loss was −2.79 kg (95% CI, −3.29 to −2.29 kg) at 150 minutes per week and −4.19 kg (95% CI, −5.98 to −2.41 kg) at 300 minutes per week (eTable 19 in Supplement 1 ).
Doctor Jason Fung, on The Diary Of A CEO, at 32:25 Video · partly · Opinion
“so very very important but in terms of weight loss it's actually a very very small effect”
Dr Michael Israetel, on The Diary Of A CEO, at 1:11:32 Video · partly · Opinion
“600s a drop and the bucket to that you'll never notice”
Dr. Lauren Colenso-Semple, on Huberman Lab, at 50:31 Video · partly · Opinion
“a lot of people are adding cardio for weight loss goals and that is a bit of a fool's errand”
Controlled trial, Obesity (Silver Spring), 2013, PMID 23592678 Study · negative
Body weight/composition Weight change over the 10 month intervention in both the 400 (-3.9 ± 4.9; 4.3%) and 600 (-5.2 ± 5.6 kg; 5.7%) kcal/session groups was significantly different than control [(0.5 ± 3.5 kg; 0.5%); Table 3 ]; however, weight change between exercise groups did not differ significantly.
Cardio is a strong tool for health and longevity even though it is weak for weight loss.
Pooled analysis, Cochrane Database Syst Rev, 2006, PMID 17054187
Positive Study
Read the paper on PubMed →When compared with no treatment, exercise resulted in small weight losses across studies.
Controlled trial, PLoS One, 2009, PMID 19223984
Positive Study
Read the paper on PubMed →In this study of previously sedentary, overweight or obese, postmenopausal women we observed no difference in the actual and predicted weight loss with 4 and 8 KKW of exercise (72 and 136 minutes respectively), while the 12 KKW (194 minutes) produced only about half of the predicted weight loss.
Controlled trial, Obesity (Silver Spring), 2012, PMID 21494229
Positive Study
Read the paper on PubMed →Participants in the diet alone group lost a mean 7.2 kg (−8.5%, P<0.0001), those in the exercise alone group lost a mean 2.0 kg (−2.4%, P=0.034), while those in the diet + exercise group lost a mean 8.9 kg (−10.8%, P<0.0001), each compared to a 0.7 kg decrease among controls.
Pooled analysis, Circulation, 2011, PMID 21810663
Positive Study
Read the paper on PubMed →Individuals who engaged in the equivalent of 150 min/week of moderate-intensity LTPA (minimum amount, 2008 US federal guidelines) had a 14% lower CHD risk (relative risk (RR) = 0.86; 95% confidence interval (CI), 0.77–0.96), compared with those reporting no LTPA.
Controlled trial, J Appl Physiol (1985), 2012, PMID 23019316
Positive Study
Read the paper on PubMed →Body mass significantly decreased in the AT and AT/RT but significantly increased in RT.
Pooled analysis, J Am Heart Assoc, 2013, PMID 23525435
Positive Study
Read the paper on PubMed →The effect of endurance training on SBP ( P <0.0001) and DBP ( P <0.0001) was greatest in 26 study groups with hypertensive participants (−8.3 [−10.7 to −6.0]/−5.2 [−6.9 to −3.4] mm Hg) compared with groups with participants with prehypertension (−4.3 [−7.7 to −0.90]/−1.7 [−2.7 to −0.68] mm Hg) or normal BP (−0.75 [−2.2 to +0.69]/−1.1 [−2.2 to −0.068] mm Hg).
Trial or observed group, J Am Coll Cardiol, 2014, PMID 25082581
Positive Study
Read the paper on PubMed →This study may motivate healthy but sedentary individuals to begin and continue running for substantial and attainable mortality benefits.
Pooled analysis, J Acad Nutr Diet, 2014, PMID 25257365
Positive Study
Read the paper on PubMed →Pooled results showed that weight loss at 3 to 6 months was significantly higher in combined programs than in those that involved physical activity alone (mean difference=–5.33 kg; 95% CI –7.61 to –3.04).
Pooled analysis, Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act, 2014, PMID 25344355
Positive Study
Read the paper on PubMed →Conclusions Walking and cycling confer 11% and 10% reductions in risk of ACM in groups that conduct 11.25 MET.hours per week.
Pooled analysis, J Am Heart Assoc, 2016, PMID 27628572
Positive Study
Read the paper on PubMed →Our findings suggest that an increase in 11.25 MET h/week for an inactive individual is associated with a reduction of risk for cardiovascular mortality by 23% and diabetes mellitus incidence by 26%, independent of body weight.
Pooled analysis, Diabetologia, 2016, PMID 27747395
Positive Study
Read the paper on PubMed →Using the restricted cubic splines model, accumulating an activity volume which is commensurate with adherence to the current public health recommendations of 150 min of MVPA per week compared with sedentary individuals was associated with a reduction in the risk of type 2 diabetes by 26% (95% CI 20%, 31%) in the general population.
Pooled analysis, Br J Sports Med, 2023, PMID 36854652
Positive Study
Read the paper on PubMed →Compared with inactive individuals, adults accumulating 8.75 mMET-hours/week had 31% (95% CI 27 to 35) and 29% (95% CI 23 to 34) lower risk of all-cause and CVD mortality, respectively, whereas the risk difference for total cancer mortality was 15% (95% CI 11 to 19).
Pooled analysis, JAMA Netw Open, 2024, PMID 39724371
Positive Study
Read the paper on PubMed →The degree of weight loss was −2.79 kg (95% CI, −3.29 to −2.29 kg) at 150 minutes per week and −4.19 kg (95% CI, −5.98 to −2.41 kg) at 300 minutes per week (eTable 19 in Supplement 1 ).
Doctor Jason Fung, on The Diary Of A CEO, at 32:25
Partly Video · Opinion
Open the tape at 32:25 →“so very very important but in terms of weight loss it's actually a very very small effect”
Dr Michael Israetel, on The Diary Of A CEO, at 1:11:32
Partly Video · Opinion
Open the tape at 1:11:32 →“600s a drop and the bucket to that you'll never notice”
Dr. Lauren Colenso-Semple, on Huberman Lab, at 50:31
Partly Video · Opinion
Open the tape at 50:31 →“a lot of people are adding cardio for weight loss goals and that is a bit of a fool's errand”
Controlled trial, Obesity (Silver Spring), 2013, PMID 23592678
Negative Study
Read the paper on PubMed →Body weight/composition Weight change over the 10 month intervention in both the 400 (-3.9 ± 4.9; 4.3%) and 600 (-5.2 ± 5.6 kg; 5.7%) kcal/session groups was significantly different than control [(0.5 ± 3.5 kg; 0.5%); Table 3 ]; however, weight change between exercise groups did not differ significantly.
Precis is not affiliated with or endorsed by YouTube or by any researcher, show or publisher we quote. We take no sponsorship, ad or affiliate money, and every verdict is our own review of what was said. How we stay independent
The verdict rests on 17 credited sources: 14 studies Precis has read in full and three sources on tape. Thirteen of the studies back the claim. One trial argues against its weight-loss half. The three tape sources back it in part, since all three speak only to weight loss. Nine more studies wait for a full read and don't count yet.
The health half rests on pooled analyses of large cohort studies. In a 2023 analysis, adults who logged 8.75 mMET-hours of free-time activity a week had a 31% lower risk of death than inactive adults. MET-hours, and the mMET-hours this study used, measure how much exercise someone does.
Their risk of death from heart and blood vessel disease was 29% lower. For an inactive person, adding 11.25 MET-hours a week went with a 23% lower risk of death from heart and blood vessel disease, even after accounting for body weight.
A pooled analysis of trials found that endurance training lowers blood pressure. In people with high blood pressure, the top number fell by 8.3 mm Hg and the bottom number by 5.2. In people with normal blood pressure, it fell far less.
Most of the longevity evidence is observational. It shows a link, not proof that cardio causes the longer life, and no study Precis read tested lifespan in a randomized trial.
A 2024 pooled analysis of trials found aerobic exercise took off 2.79 kg at 150 minutes a week and 4.19 kg at 300 minutes. In a trial in postmenopausal women, diet alone took off 7.2 kg and exercise alone 2.0 kg. A Cochrane review found small weight losses from exercise against no treatment.
The one study against this half is a 10-month trial. Men and women whose sessions burned 400 or 600 calories lost 3.9 kg (4.3%) and 5.2 kg (5.7%).
On tape, Jason Fung, a guest on The Diary of a CEO, calls exercise very important but says its effect on weight loss is very small. Mike Israetel, a guest on the same show, works out that an extra 600 calories a week from running is a drop in the bucket next to diet. Lauren Colenso-Semple, a guest on Andrew Huberman's show, calls adding cardio for weight loss a fool's errand.
Benjamin Levine, a guest on Patrick's show, says more physical activity lowers the risk of atrial fibrillation, an irregular heartbeat, up to a point. Past that point, very long and intense endurance training raises it. His remarks are not counted toward this claim.
Precis membership
The answer above is the whole answer: the verdict, every counted mention, where the sources disagree, and the receipt behind each one. Nothing on this page is held back.
A free account adds
Pro adds
Full VO2 Max evidence report
The verdict on every claim, and where the sources disagree