Expert Answer
Quick Answer
4 of 5 experts support collagen for skin, but Attia is skeptical — calling it a 'low-quality protein.' Huberman recommends 15g daily for skin elasticity. Johnson takes collagen peptides daily. All agree: it's not for muscle building.
Strong Consensus
on Collagen overall
Recommends 15g daily for skin elasticity. 5-30g/day for skin thinning. Pair with vitamin C.
Takes collagen peptides daily in morning drink and breakfast. HBOT increased his collagen fiber density.
Calls collagen 'low-quality protein' that does not outperform whey for connective tissue synthesis.
Uses hydrolyzed collagen powder in her smoothie. Highlights glycine and proline for wound healing.
Collagen for skin has moderate evidence. Huberman recommends approximately 15g daily (5-30g range for skin thinning), always paired with vitamin C for synthesis support. Johnson takes it daily and HBOT increased his collagen fiber density.
Attia is the notable skeptic — his analysis with Dr. Luc van Loon concludes collagen does not outperform dairy protein for connective tissue synthesis. He calls it a "low-quality protein."
The consensus: collagen may help skin (several RCTs show improvements in elasticity), but should never replace whey for muscle building. Always pair with vitamin C.
Clinical trials typically show improvements in skin elasticity and hydration within 8-12 weeks of daily supplementation.
This page covers what researchers agree on. Pro gives you the specific dosages, timing schedules, and interaction warnings they each recommend — with video citations you can verify.
Cancel anytime
Full Collagen Consensus Report
See what all 5 experts agree and disagree on